Get help now

Corporal Punishment Between Parents and their Children



  • Pages 3
  • Words 646
  • Views 343
  • Can’t find relevant credible information

    Let our experts help you

    Get help now

    I am writing in reply to the recent publication of an item on the topic of

    corporal punishment. I do not agree that it is needed to bring discipline back into our

    schools. It is assumed that a child who has been caned would be less likely to commit

    another offence , but this was never proved and , in fact , one theory holds that severe

    corporal punishment increases the likelihood of future offences.

    There are better ways to discipline students than hitting them. Some parents may

    believe that spanking a child may be beneficial but apart from being potentially

    dangerous physically, it can lower their self esteem, hinder their academic abilities

    and may even contribute to disruptive and violent behaviour. Some pupils may feel so

    afraid to go to school that they are tempted to play truant.

    Over the past few years we have become more and more obsessive over bringing our

    lives into the twenty first century and now , here you are telling us that we should

    bring back corporal punishment, a system which is looked upon as old fashioned !

    Discipline should begin in the home . Parents have and should accept the task

    of instilling in their children respect for right and wrong, respect for others and all the

    other basic lessons of living, working, playing and learning with others. They should

    try to teach him to control himself and take responsibility for his actions and their

    consequences .Unfortunately, because some parents find it difficult to do this from

    infancy , the teachers role is all the more difficult. Still, restoring this rule is not the

    way to resolve theses difficulties. Get to children in infancy and their early years and

    their lives will be shaped more fully for future growth. Restoring their teachers’

    power to hit them across the bottom or knuckles doesn’t fit that picture. Forget

    Roald Dahl’s book entitled “Boy” tells about the times when corporal

    punishment was allowed to take place in all schools. A passage from the book tells of

    how , aged nine, Dahl was caned six times for talking during prep. Even though he

    had had a perfectly good excuse he got the same punishment another child would

    probably have got for defacing school property or stealing. I think that this reinforces

    my earlier suggestion that teachers may take advantage of their authority and harass

    pupils they may have taken a dislike to. Dahl states in his book “the fear of the

    dreaded cane hung over us like the fear of death all the time” and “the cruel cane

    ruled our lives…. we were caned for doing everything that it was natural for small

    Summerhill is the opposite extreme. It is a school in England dedicated to

    providing an environment where pupils can be themselves. There are only a few rules

    to abide by although these do not include necessity to attend classes, no set bedtimes,

    swearing is acceptable and all pupils are free to express themselves in whatever way

    they feel suits them best . Problems are sorted out at the Meetings and punishment is

    no more than suspension for a set period of time depending on the offence.

    Due to the lack of discipline there is a constant worry about bullying and other forms

    of violence in Summerhill. A compromise between the harshness of corporal

    punishment and the total lack of discipline in situations such as that in Summerhill is

    the system that is currently in use in Northern Ireland today

    So I remain in the opinion that corporal punishment is unfair and should not

    be allowed to return to schools as a form of discipline. If you are genuinely trying to

    show pupils how to behave you will not need to hurt or shame them. Behavior which

    is anti-social will bring with it its own uncomfortable consequences.

    Thankyou for taking the time to read though my letter.

    Corporal Punishment Between Parents and their Children. (2018, Jun 14). Retrieved from

    Hi, my name is Amy 👋

    In case you can't find a relevant example, our professional writers are ready to help you write a unique paper. Just talk to our smart assistant Amy and she'll connect you with the best match.

    Get help with your paper