Is Healthcare a Right
A basic human right is something all people should have access too or one’s ability to exercise a particular action themselves. The right to vote, speak freely, bear arms and freedom to practice religion are all rights of an individual. To deny individuals the availability to their best possible health or a right such as healthcare has a monumental impact that is far more reaching than just ones individual health and longevity in life. People deserve the right to healthcare and the ability to live a healthy and productive life.
By law, no hospital can deny medical service to any person needing emergency medical care regardless of whether a person is with or without medical insurance coverage The law means everyone and anyone. A drug dealer who may have a negative impact on society or the immigrant that has just landed on US soil. Healthcare in the United States is rightly designed to make accessible to all people, but depending on one’s insurance coverage the quality of healthcare received can vary in many ways. The quantity of insurance carriers and programs and how Americans receive healthcare has always been subject to conversation.
Need essay sample on "Is Healthcare a Right" ? We will write a custom essay sample specifically for you for only $12.90/page
America’s health system is a very complex free-market enterprise that is designed to provide care to individuals or families. Most other countries around the world provide healthcare to all citizens and that care is paid for or subsidized by government funding and financing through taxation. Even though the American healthcare system is the most technologically advanced and can provide the best care in the world, it falls short of being obtainable and affordable to each and every citizen therefore leaving much of the nation without healthcare or the right to protect their physical and mental health.
Healthcare as a right or not is a huge debate with a tall fence dividing the two. Dr. Erin Gilliland’s opinion in his book, Justice for All-Saving Justice in America, approaches healthcare as a service to people; not a right to people. “The only way to make healthcare a “right” is if we were to make slaves of everyone in the entire healthcare industry, remove their free will, and force them to provide healthcare free on demand to anyone who chose to exercise their “right” to healthcare”, is Dr. Gilliland’s firm statement.
This statement has logic and respects the freedom of an individual’s earnings and what he or she proceeds to do with them, however it is a little extreme. Claiming that people would become the idea of a “slave” for allowing a system of healthcare that is rightful to each person and that would be so called “free” would be no different than what each person gives a chunk of their salary up already for taxes and for our “free” highways, social security and departments such as the Defense and International security.
To form this bias, much else in the economic industry would be a system of “slavery” and in many cases removal of free will. The positive effects coming from the opinion that healthcare should not be a right would not be much different than the effects of how our system works today. Although there is not one single entity or Insurance Company that controls the system; several insurance companies make millions to billions of dollars while the majority of the nation is left uninsured or under-insured. The US healthcare system operates in stark contract when compared to other countries.
For example, according to the GlobalPost, German insurance companies compete with each other as non-profit companies while here in America, insurance companies gross billions of dollars. Positive effects of a changing to a system like Germany’s would benefit sellers of healthcare, doctors, and other employees who perform services and receive pay due to money being distributed elsewhere than insurers’. However, within this idea, hospitals would still be losing money like they do today by providing care to those who have no insurance but cannot be turned away from emergency attention and care.
For a nation that pays the highest rates of healthcare in the world per person, it does not ensure a fair, equitable process that measures that outcome of those who are insured. To exercise common rights such as freedom of speech and voting, people should be in good health to be able to take advantage of their constitutional or natural rights. The right to receive assistance in health when needed is something the rest of the world agrees with along with America. Not to say the American health system does not provide beneficial are and save countless lives, however, it also does the opposite. Republican John Dingell of the Roll Call newspaper makes a statement that reveals the negative side of our healthcare system.
“The high cost of healthcare causes a bankruptcy every 30 seconds. By the end of the year, it will cause 1. 5 million Americans to lose their homes. Premiums have grown four times faster than wages over the past eight years, and in each of these years, a million more Americans have lost their health insurance. The brutal premiums and costs to afford healthcare, especially without benefits from employers and jobs, is where the difficulty in getting a functioning healthcare system starts. The unfortunate fact of the matter is that if wages of doctors and insurers were reduced, there would be a reduction of quality among services. The average debt accumulated among medical graduate students in 2012 is around $160,000. If doctor’s wages were to be cut, the man hours put through medical school would not seem so beneficial therefore possibly leaving an even greater shortage of MD’s.
Likewise, it is not easy or simply logical to tell an insurance company that their annual income will be lowered. This system of healthcare in America has been somewhat broken for years and been continuing to function while broken, leaving a greater mess to clean up every year. It is hard to change something that is already in motion and even harder to change a system that affects millions of people on a daily basis. However with struggle and difficulty comes progress. No right worth fighting for has ever been simple or else there would be no significance.
Healthcare to every human being should be a right because it is their health, their existence and their life. Money is the root of nearly all systems in the world and it is being made the golden ticket to be able to receive benefits to one’s health and wellness of life. The management of money and balance of receive and pay should be the first change among many to this “system”.
Dingell, J. (2009). Dingell: Healthcare should be a right, not a privelege. Retrieved September, 3, 2012, from http://www. rollcall. om/features/Health-Care_2009/health_care/-33327-1. html Gilliland, E. (2012). Is healthcare a right?. Retrieved September, 3, 2012, from http://www. savingjustice. org/77-is-health-care-a-right Kuther, D. T. (2010-2011). How much does medical school cost?. Retrieved September, 3, 2012, from http://gradschool. about. com/od/medicalschool/f/MedSchoolCost. htm? rd=1 Paul Hockenos. (May 30, 2010). Is germany’s health care a good model for the US?. Retrieved September, 3, 2012, from http://www. globalpost. com/dispatch/germany/091008/germanys-health-care-model? page=0,1