Separation of School and State Essay

The Separation of School and State

Families, these days, are becoming more and more religious; yet they can not

We will write a custom essay sample on
Separation of School and State
specifically for you for only $13.9/page
Order now

More Essay Examples on

decide if religion should actually be a part of the school day - Separation of School and State Essay introduction. Whether or not religion

should be allowed in public schools is a very controversial issue. Some people strongly

oppose it, and some strongly support it. In fact, they support it so much that the parents

are choosing to pull their children from the public school systems. For decades now,

since 1962, when the U.S. Supreme Court threw prayer out of schools in the case of

Engle V. Vitale (“school prayer…” 1), the separation of school and church has been a

In recent years there has been a rapid growth of teen-prayer groups being

formed. These groups, mostly made up of Christian teens, raise some major concerns

(Newcomb 1). Although religious groups are not allowed to meet during the regular

school day, they can meet after and before school. As a result of so many groups,

children that are not Christian are beginning to question and try their own faith. These

children, the minority, feel left out and uncomfortable. In a survey that was conducted in

Lincoln High School, sixteen students were asked if they would feel left out if students

were publically leading group prayers. The results were varied, although most said they

One anti-religion activist states, “Public schools are for all children, no matter the

religion, and are supported by all taxpayers, and therefore should be free of religious

observances.” Another states, “Religion is private, and schools are public-so it is

appropriate that they shouldn’t mix (Riley 1). One pro-religion activist responds,

“Schools where clubs of different faiths operate, students can learn to coexist, be

sensitive to different points of view, while still strengthening their own spiritual and moral

beliefs (Newcomb 1). During those after school meetings a school official needs to be

present at all times to not only ensure that the club members promote their activities in a

way that doesn’t offend others, but also to prevent adult manipulation (1).

Many parents and adults consider the uprising of crime and the lowering of

values in society a result of taking prayers out of schools (“School Prayer…” 1). Public

schools are thought by many as pagan, anti-Christian, and unbiblical. When Christian

mother, Nancy McFarland’s daughter gave birth to an out-of-wedlock child, she blamed

libertine teachers for promoting premarital sex (a sin in a Christian’s mind). McFarland

states, “Public schooling is no longer about educating children; it’s about destroying their

minds” (Koerner 54). Children are beginning to feel torn between their parents views,

and the views that they have. When asked if they felt obligated to believe the same

beliefs as their parents and peers, the majority of the students surveyed said no. But,

what does this mean? According to Riley, “Religion should not tear people apart, it

should bring them together. The students of today should be able to make decisions for

themselves, and decide what they want. We are taking this ‘gift’ of choice away from

our children. We are forcing them to believe what we want them to believe” (Riley 2).

Several groups have begun to appear, both pro-Christian, and anti-Christian, to

try to separate church and state. Groups such as Exodus 2000, Rescue 2010, and

Separation of School and State Alliance have some very far fetched, and unlikely goals.

Rescue 2010’s goal is to “exit” every Christian child from the public school system within

a decade (by the year 2010). There are currently about twenty-million Christian children

enrolled in public schools. These groups believe that schools center on multiculturalism,

the absence of prayer, and sex-ed (Koerner 54). Barry Lynn, the executive director of

Americans United for Separation of Church and State argues, “It’s [Exodus 2000] based

on this premise that public schools are pure evil, and they are spiritually raping your

Most Christian parents that support school prayer view that not only does it

[prayer] help make the transition into learning smooth, and it also helps students to

resolve personal issues. Prayers give students, no matter the religion, time every

morning where they think about values and faith to help them through life. Many

students have problems and prayer gives them time for them to think about their issues.

Supporters view that starting the day off with prayer will not harm society. They see it

as a “way of allowing…students to clear their minds” (“School Prayer…” 1). One

supporter of organized religion in school states, “Kids are to often found dead as gang

members, or having children out of wedlock. Prayer promotes peace and abstinence in

almost every organized religion. It is absolutely vital to maintain moral health in our

society. Prayer may cause children to become better human-beings, better members of

society, and better parents for our young” (“School Prayer…” 1).

Many children and adults have been tried in the United States Supreme Court for

violating the court’s ruling of the 1962 case Engel V. Vitale. The ruling the court made

defines what the first amendment’s “Freedom of Religion” really means to us today.

Prior to the Supreme Court’s decision, the only person that had to actually utter a word

during the prayer was the teacher, and no teacher complained. Students did not have

to say a word, and could even leave the classroom if they desired (Bryce 26).

The latest, and widely publicized case that was taken to the Supreme Court took

place in Stephanville, Texas. Joel Allen, and Alan Ward, both 15-year-old football

players, decided that nothing, not even a federal court ruling-was going to keep them

from praying. On August 27, 1999, before the coin-toss of the school’s football game,

the two borrowed a P.A. system. Using the P.A. system, the two students led the crowd

in a prayer. Allen stated that, “We decided to stand for God, and overlook man’s laws,

the short prayer before the game is a tradition, and I intend to keep it that way. Here in

Texas, football and religion are taken seriously. Football is a religion.” Although the

court ruled that events like football games are “hardly the sober type of annual event

that can be solemnized with prayer,” Allen and Ward are planning a repeat performance

When someone is willing to go to such an extreme measure as to break a federal

law more than once for a cause they truly believe in, they should be recognized and

praised, not taunted and punished. “Sufferings gladly borne for others convert more

people than sermons” (dc 207). Robert Simonds, president of CEE (Citizens for

Excellent Education), brings up the point that the courts are actually doing these kids a

favor. As Jesus is quoted in the Bible:

“Don’t be upset when they haul you before the civil authorities. Without knowing

it, they’ve done you-and me-a favor, given you a platform for preaching the kingdom

news! And don’t worry about what you’ll say, or how you say it. The right words will be

there. The Spirit of your Father will supply the words” (dc 146).

A libertarian stated, “There is a huge move toward more religious expression

among students during the school day. Schools need to make policies so that people

will understand the boundaries” (Van Biema 61). There are two “documents”that protect

and limit prayer in public schools. The obvious one would be the Constitution, or the Bill

of Rights; the less known one is the “Equal Access Act.” This document reads that all

federally funded schools have to allow religious meetings if they also host other clubs,

not related to the curriculum (Newcomb 1).

Contrary to what many think, prayer is, in fact, allowed in the public school

system, school houses, at the flag pole, in student religious clubs, and in the cafeteria;

however, it is not normally permitted in the class room when class is in session

(“Religion…” 1). The powers that the schools have to enforce these laws are limited

though. Schools are not allowed to stop a student from praying, as long as it doesn’t

disrupt the class, although it touches on the religious beliefs and tolerances of many.

(“School Prayer…” 1). The first amendment requires that public school teachers,

principals, and boards be religiously neutral, they may not promote a particular religion

as superior to any other (“Religion…” 1). Schools are also prohibited from many

religious related acts, such as: requiring students to recite prayers in class, public

prayers at high school games, requiring students to partake in a moment of silence,

promoting any one denomination or religion at the expense of another, banning the

wearing of religious clothing and symbols, and prayers before education meetings. It

also requires schools to drop a line containing the word “God” out of the Pledge of

Allegiance. Students can, however: Pray before eating, Hand out religious materials,

Freely talk about religion to peers, Study the positive/negative effects of religion, Carry

Bibles or any other religious text, and they can Organize prayers on school ground,

outside of the classroom (“Religion…” 1).

The topic of religion in school is very debatable, and has many journalists,

authors, and editors expressing their opinions through publications. There are some

very good sources that thoroughly explain the thoughts, debates, and actions of those

working for or against the combination of school and state. An article from the Internet

entitled “Religion in the U.S. Public Schools” is a really helpful source. There are lots of

lists of pros and cons, and numerous amounts of reasons why people are ‘pro’ or ‘anti’

school and state. It is a great unbiased source. Newcomb’s piece, “Praying at School,”

and Riley’s piece, “Religion and Public Schools,” were just as useful, and had a lot of the

same information. Van Biema’s article, “The Day God Took Over,” was not very useful

at all. The interview conducted with Mr. Matt Oxford gave an adults intake on the

subject. He more or less leaned toward being in favor of religion in school. The survey

that was conducted on six-teen tenth grade students at Lincoln High School in Lake City

was pretty much varied. Its hard to tell whether or not the students were answering the

survey truthfully, or if they were just messing around. Although the survey may not be

totally accurate, it does give a pretty good intake on what the students think. It is pretty

hard to thoroughly understand what the students want when only six-teen are surveyed,

but, it gives an idea. There was not very much information relevant to the sub-topics of

religion in school that I picked. The interview and the survey gave different results than

read about in any of the other sources. The information that was acquired from the

survey/interview gave personal and group feelings. It gives more of a local outlook on

this topic. No matter what type of media is searched, there will always be new ideas

and arguments being published; some sources just are more relevant than others.

Religion in public schools (church and state) is a very heated issue that historians

believe even Jesus was unsure about. Jesus stated, “Thou shalt not be as the

hypocrites are: For they love to pray standing in synagogues and in corners of the

streets, that they may be seen of men…But thou, when thou prayest enter into thy

closet, and when thou hast shut thy door, pray to thy Father, which is in secret” (Riley

1). Robert Simmonds states, “You can only put people under the gun so long, I think we

are approaching a national revolt against the government that is unreceptive to it’s

people’s needs, and it’s children’s futures” (Koerner 54). Through all the arguing and

disagreements that are heard over this issue, not many are concerned with what the

students want. When asked if they would feel uncomfortable if the school day was

started with a group prayer, the six-teen students were pretty much varied. Some would

feel uncomfortable, while the same amount on about either other way would not care, or

Both the interview and the survey asked approximately the same questions. The

questions that were used centered around the opinions and the view points of not only

the students but also an adult. The questions that were chosen, were questions that

would maybe help to explain and find out exactly how the students feel. The results

seem to have proven that religion in the public schools is somewhat a “sore” subject that

no matter what happens, not everyone will agree whether or not religion should be a

part of everyday school life. From the information that was acquired from the

survey/interview, it can be said that students are less likely to take religious comments

as a threat. Mr. Oxford states, “By teaching religion in schools, not only Christianity,

mind you, the students learn diversity. Diversity is a necessity in today’s world, and this

should be looked at as a good thing. It will help if students learn that they will encounter

people of other religions in their life, and they will not and should not throw a fit about it.

Some adults are just worried their children will start to contradict them. We need to

have a little faith in our children” (interview).

The separation of church and state is going to continue to be a heated topic until

the “anti”and the “pro” groups dissolve and become one, a group that is looking at the

Bibliography

Bryce, Robert. “To Pray-or Not to Pray.” US. News and World Report. Sept.

13, 1999: p26.

dc Talk and the Voice of the Martyrs. Jesus Freaks. Tulsa: Albury
Publishing, 1999.

Koerner, Brandon I. “When is it OK to Drop Out of School?” US. News and
World Report. June 12, 2000: p54.

McAshland, Norm. Personal interview. Nov. 10, 2000.

Newcomb, Amelia. “Praying at School.” Christian Science: June 16, 1998.

(Sept. 23, 2000).

“Religion in the US. Public Schools.” 1998.

(Sept. 23,
2000).

Riley, Richard W. “Religion and Public Schools.”1998.

(Sept. 23, 2000).

“School Prayer: A Dividing Line of American Values.”1998.

(Sept. 23, 2000).

Surveys. Lake City, MN. Nov. 2000.

Van Biema, David. “The Day God Took Over.” Time. June 5, 2000: p61.

Choose Type of service

Choose writer quality

Page count

1 page 275 words

Deadline

Order Creative Sample Now

Haven’t Found A Paper?

Let us create the best one for you! What is your topic?

By clicking "SEND", you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy. We'll occasionally send you account related and promo emails.

Eric from Graduateway Hi there, would you like to get an essay? What is your topic? Let me help you

logo

Haven't found the Essay You Want?

Get your custom essay sample

For Only $13.90/page