Get help now

Parking Utilization Boulevard Consumer Square Purple Zone Tourism

  • Pages 8
  • Words 1813
  • Views 328
  • dovnload



  • Pages 8
  • Words 1813
  • Views 328
  • Academic anxiety?

    Get original paper in 3 hours and nail the task

    Get your paper price

    124 experts online

    The influence of parking ordinances in the United States has followed the tendency of urban conurbation. Parking tonss are attached to many concerns and are regulated by the authorities on a local degree. These parking tonss present the chance to closely analyse the ordinances set Forth and their effectivity. Government ordinances and development criterions are to be tested in order to understand, analyze and construe the use of their current constellation. This analysis ‘ purpose bases to make an image of the zone as a map of use and overall operation.

    The site of analysis is the Boulevard Consumer Square in Buffalo, New York. On Niagara Falls Boulevard the place sits in a part that has been overcome with the conurbation of commercial retail. These strips of retail are largely concatenation franchises that were built at different times. The physical landscape of the parking lots reveals this inconsistent development method. The sum of parking to the consumer ‘s oculus has become both an eyesore every bit good as a waste of otherwise valuable and useable infinite. During regular concern hours every bit good as after, the tonss seem to ne’er make full up. By looking at Donald Shoup ‘s book High Cost of Free Parking an illation can be made as to the grounds for these parking demands in a retailing division such as Boulevard Consumer Square. These demands have become an unneeded nuisance that need to be carefully analyzed and evaluated to better understand and follow better ordinances that fit the altering urban environment.


    The natural information was collected on a Tuesday dark ( September 7, 2010 ) at 5:48 autopsy ( -5:57 autopsy ) . This twenty-four hours and clip was chosen due to the nature of the consumer traffic through the country. At this clip, the environing eating house constitutions would be making a good trade of concern. Besides, this is after many people get out of work and halt for food markets or speedy shopping before traveling place to dinner. This was determined to be a peak clip of human traffic in the country. The border of mistake lies in the lone one conducted study of infinite tenancy. More visits to the site at changing times would let for a better apprehension of the use degrees and peak/non-peak times.

    The intent, as antecedently stated, is to set up a current use degree in the designated country. The specific country is the parking in forepart of Target, Petsmart, AC Moore, GolfGalaxy, and Bed Bath & A ; Beyond. There is no empty retail infinite in this stretch of commercial real property. Occupancy was based on the figure of autos parked during the period of clip spent numbering their infinites. Cars needed to be parked right in a infinite in order to be counted in the natural information. Cars that were standing or illicitly crossing/cutting through lanes were non counted. The comparing of parking batch tenancy was separately based on entire infinites of each batch. From the observation of drivers and walkers likewise, the experiential infinite is one that is insistent and non distinctive. There are no characteristics which define the infinite besides the autos that occupy it.

    Analysis & A ; Consequences

    After making a SWOT analysis of the zone it is obvious that the physical layout every bit good as the methodological analysis has changed with clip. The facade of Target every bit good as the parking tonss infinites were redesigned in an effort to better traffic flow and make a more gratifying experience. The focal point of this analysis is on traffic flow and morphology, physical design, congestion and traffic forms, every bit good as the experiential infinite.

    The zone is divided into three parking tonss. The first consists of 422 infinites that are located in forepart of the Target on the southeast terminal of the place. The 2nd parking batch consists of 364 infinites that are located in forepart of the retail infinites to the E of Target: Petsmart, AC Moore, GolfGalaxy, and Bed Bath & A ; Beyond. The 3rd batch is located behind the retail infinites and consists of merely 13 infinites. Due to the nature of this undertaking, the 3rd batch will chiefly be disregarded. See Figure 1 for a elaborate analysis and dislocation of natural informations. See figure 3 for a perceptual function of the informations.

    Figure 1. Raw information collected Tuesday, September 7, 2010.

    April Hickey & A ; Ben Lytle.Occupancy rates in the parking tonss were alarmingly low. The Target parking batch recorded at 41 % tenancy while the staying commercial strip batch recorded merely 17 % full. This supports the suggestion that parking ordinance demands are non run intoing the demand of the populace. These demands of lower limits oversize these tonss to run into the demands at extremum times of the twelvemonth, which is a little per centum of shopping yearss. Are these demands necessary when the consequences of such ordinances are lying useless in paving oblivion?

    Figure 2. Formal SWOT Analysis. To travel frontward with development and suggestions, understanding the current state of affairs is necessary. It is of import to find facets to concentrate and construct upon every bit good as acknowledging countries in demand of improvement.Dr. Shoup states in his book that parking supply does non constrict demand for parking. There is statistically an glut ( +0.5-1 infinite by square footage ) . The highest demand is for a few hours of a twelvemonth. Shoup besides states that in the US merely 2 % of shopping centres charge parking fees for clients. 1 % made it compulsory for their employees to pay besides for their parking agreements ( Shoup ) . This is a little visible radiation at the terminal of a long tunnel of ignorance for what consumers really pay for when they visit commercial retail centres. Awareness is the first measure to deriving the support of the general working category citizens which support the parking substructure.

    The first measure of the analysis procedure was to make a SWOT analysis of the country. Properly acknowledging the strengths, failings, chances and menaces is a proven successful method of puting out all facets of an country. The countries in demand of betterment are recognized as the physical design, traffic flow through and into/out of the country. The job is created because of the irregular development that occurred in this commercial place. The different countries ( i.e. how this area/project was divided up into different zones ) are seen as separate and distinguishable, non one entity as a place. This separation is good represented in the physical programs. These are the positives and negatives ( see Figure 2 ) from internal and external forces upon the survey country. This analysis calls into play the political and community issues every bit good as physical properties.

    Flow and mobility jobs affect many if non all users of this zone. Accessibility nodes to the zone are located at the northwest 4-way intersection every bit good as the southwest 4-way intersection. See Figure 4. These two countries disrupt the traffic flow to, from, and through the country. It hinders mobility ( easiness of motion ) for both drivers and walkers. Tough flow countries are drawn in ruddy while countries with good flow are green. The two callouts call attending to the disability required infinites and easiness of motion from these infinites to the shopfronts. The physical landscape every bit good as day-to-day traffic forms along the rows affects the result of the experience for a client utilizing these infinites.

    Figure 3. Percentage Occupancy by row in relationship to commercial entrywaies in the Purple Zone. ( 0 % -100 % graduated table ) .

    Figure 4. Transportation system Flow and Morphology Potential Map. Traffic flow feasibleness in relationship to shopfronts. Handiness by disabled persons and their forced direct/indirect paths.

    Space picks are made based on the undermentioned: convenience, location, and monetary value ( Shoup ) . The convenience factor is represented by the bunch of the autos within a certain radius of the front entryway to shops. In peculiar, a hapless design determination is Target ‘s entryway location within pess of a 4-way intersection that does non line up right on an east-west axis. This causes congestion jobs and the potency of safety issues for car-users and walkers likewise.

    Figure 5. Picture by Ben Lytle.


    The analysis proves the theory that these parking tonss are underutilized and possesses possible to be transformed into a more appropriate use. Further research into potencies will be made. However for the clip being, the ordinances should be looked at and re-evaluated. By making a system of cheques and balances in the parking tonss ( through shop inducements or parking proof ) the local concerns can relieve some of the financess associated with upkeep for parking. The public needs to be informed of their cost of parking and understand their market value. These demands are made as lower limits for topographic points that have no manner to foretell a future consumer base. A figure of parking infinites dictated by square footage makes sense. However, when we calculated the sum of necessary infinites, the shop does non run into the demands. This may be for a assortment of grounds. The degree at which the parking infinite demand is non known ( i.e. shop by shop, connected franchises, place ) .[ 1 ]

    Square Footage of Target-125,302 ft2

    Square Footage of Petsmart, AC Moore, GolfGalaxy, and Bed Bath & A ; Beyond-83,415 ft2

    Entire Square Footage – 208,717ft2

    Zoning ordinance mandates 85 % of leasable infinite is counted when accounting for parking infinites.

    208,717ft2 ten.85 = 177,409.45 ft2

    5 infinites per 1,000 square pess.

    177,409.45 ft2 / 1,000 ft2 = 177.40945 ft2

    177.40945 ft2 x 5 = 887.05 parking infinites required.

    Actual parking infinites provided: 819

    The physical design of the asphalt no-man’s-land is extremely underutilizes with merely 29 % of the full parking infinites being used. This is the combination of two tonss. The bulk of infinite use is closest to the shop entrywaies, peculiarly Target, which is expected because of the shop type and square footage. The autos are physically aligned in a radius about the shop entrywaies. There is a spot of irregular parking, most likely due to the fact that it is free and available parking and a auto can be left there for a length of clip with no reverberations. This is a disagreeable freedom that needs to be looked at a reevaluated.


    Poor physical design coupled with consumer attitude and a assortment of other factors had led to the realisation of underutilization of the paving. Our Numberss prove the theory of underutilization in this zone and the inefficient gateways into the zone.

    In Donald Shoup ‘s book High Cost of Free Parking he analyzes the ordinance of parking in the U.S. This analysis is a trial of the theory of parking ordinance and whether this ordinance ( parking infinite lower limits ) really hinders the facets of the country. Again, these include the physical design flower stalk, traffic flow and forms, and experiential infinite. This analysis has proven the inefficiency of these ordinances on a local degree. The connexion between this country and others studied is similar and can be taken to that degree. The possible is enormous and needs even farther rating.

    This essay was written by a fellow student. You may use it as a guide or sample for writing your own paper, but remember to cite it correctly. Don’t submit it as your own as it will be considered plagiarism.

    Need a custom essay sample written specially to meet your requirements?

    Choose skilled expert on your subject and get original paper with free plagiarism report

    Order custom paper Without paying upfront

    Parking Utilization Boulevard Consumer Square Purple Zone Tourism. (2017, Aug 16). Retrieved from

    Hi, my name is Amy 👋

    In case you can't find a relevant example, our professional writers are ready to help you write a unique paper. Just talk to our smart assistant Amy and she'll connect you with the best match.

    Get help with your paper
    We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy