Protection and Freedom in “Saturday Climbing” Analysis

Read Summary

The topic of protection versus freedom is controversial, as younger generations crave autonomy while adults fear negative experiences for them. In the short story Saturday Climbing by Valgardson, the author suggests that protectiveness can overpower freedom in relationships, as seen through the conflicts between Barry and Moria. Barry believes Moria is too young and irresponsible to venture on her own, causing a rift in their relationship. This resonates with personal experiences, as the desire for freedom was limited by parental protectiveness, hindering learning through experience. Ultimately, the balance between protection and freedom is a delicate one, with both sides needing consideration.

Table of Content

The topic of protection versus freedom is highly contentious. As individuals, we can comprehend this dilemma. Young people typically yearn for freedom, wishing to find their place and make their own choices. Conversely, adults, having had negative experiences, do not want younger individuals to go through the same hardships. In the story “Saturday Climbing” by Valgardson, the author implies that one’s desire to protect can overpower another person’s freedom.

This text illustrates the disunity between Barry and Moria, as well as my own past experiences. Throughout the story, we witness multiple conflicts between Barry and Moria. The first indication of their disunity is when Barry privately contemplates the argument they had over Moria’s decision to go away to college. He believes that Moria, being only 16 years old and two years ahead in school, is irresponsible and too young to be independent.

I can empathize with Moria because I have gone through a similar situation, albeit on a smaller scale. When I was 14, I always longed to visit my friend’s or cousin’s house independently. Unfortunately, my mom would reject my request and utter phrases like, “Take your brother along” or “You’re not permitted to go alone.” Like Moria, I desired the freedom to choose my own destinations, but our parents’ protective nature confined us. Sadly, excessive protection hinders a crucial learning avenue for children – experience.

Cite this page

Protection and Freedom in “Saturday Climbing” Analysis. (2016, Dec 23). Retrieved from

Remember! This essay was written by a student

You can get a custom paper by one of our expert writers

Order custom paper Without paying upfront