Differences and similarities between prescriptive and descriptive schools of strategy

Table of Content

In the finding of the differences and similarities between normative and descriptive schools of scheme, we foremost have to look at the significance of scheme, strategic degrees and how scheme can be managed by different organisations. By definition scheme is a way and range of an organisation over the long term, which achieves advantage in altering environment through its constellation of resources and competencies with the purpose of carry throughing stakeholder outlooks. ( Scholes et al 2008 pp 2 )Nevertheless Michael Porter ( 1996 ) defined different as the manner of accomplishing competitory advantage by moving different and presenting alone value added to the clients.

In extra to that Baker defined scheme as the model that provide counsel for action to be taken and at the same clip it shaped by the action taken ( ( Baker J M 2007 pp 23 ) , but others kept some statement and say that scheme is non all about planning but is about utilizing careful analysis to understand and act upon a company ‘s place in the market topographic point.Strategic direction is about understanding the strategic place of an organisation, strategic picks for the hereafter and turning the scheme into action, it involves analysis of the house ‘s external and internal environments towards doing strategic determinations and pulling out comprehensive action program for accomplishing long term organisation end, ( Johnson G, 2005 ) , besides strategic direction can besides be define as extraction of present actions for the hereafter and in bend going an action vehicle so as to incorporate and commit the setup of alteration, ( Kanter R M, 1984 ) .Whittington strategic attack has been more sociological than managerial attack to the survey of concern scheme. In consideration of Whittington attack ( 2002 ) , he has four different position about strategic.

This essay could be plagiarized. Get your custom essay
“Dirty Pretty Things” Acts of Desperation: The State of Being Desperate
128 writers

ready to help you now

Get original paper

Without paying upfront

He identifies these four “ theories of action ” in the concern schemes as follows: classical planning attack, evolutionary attack, prosecusial attack and systematic attack.This classical attack has been explained by Whittington as the highest end of concern and rational planning as the agencies to achieve it. This attack to scheme requires that directors be ready and capable of following net income maximizing scheme through rational long term planning. This includes specifying the mission of the administration and puting aims, making SWOT analysis and specifying scheme of the administration, ( Whittington, 2002 ) .

Evolutionary attack is more into seeing the preparation of scheme as a imperfect method which is guided by market restraints and leads to the triumph of the most efficient and productive organisation guided by its scheme, ( Whittington,2002 ) .Prosecusial attack looks at the formation of scheme as an on-going procedure which comes to the terminal through some constructive treatments and dissensions. Since, the scheme is an on-going procedure ; it is hard to spell out scheme even after understandings. ( Whittington, 2002 ) .

Systematic attack defines scheme as an result of societal forces deep inside the society. The options are limited due to the cultural and institutional involvements of society as a whole and non considered in fragments. In this attack the organisation is non merely made up persons but with societal groups with involvements. The variables that systematic contend with are category and professions, states and provinces, households and gender.

The scheme so depends on the societal environment of the house, ( Whittington, 2002 )Having scheme in an organisation is really of import because it helps on how to run into the ends in consideration with the organisation ‘s state of affairs. An organisation scheme replies all inquiries about cardinal concern whether to concentrate in individual concern or construct a group of several concerns, either to travel for a wide scope of clients or to concentrate on a market niche, either to concentrate on a broad or narrow merchandise line, whether to establish on competitory advantage with low cost or merchandise distinction. ( Strickland J and Thomson A. 2003, pp10 )An organisation has to cognize profoundly everything concerned strategic direction, strategic degrees, and has to make to the degree of accomplishment of the strategic ends.

Organizations besides use scheme as the most of import tool for be aftering different activities consequently in order to run into their aims. Strategic direction plays different functions in the organisation which include defined organisation concern, saying the organisation mission and organizing strategic vision, evaluate public presentation, reexamining new developments and originating disciplinary accommodations.Different organisations look the concern scheme in different image ; this is because each of those organisations has got its ain formation and manner to implement its ain scheme. Some organisations take concern scheme as a mixture of fortune and opinion or self-interest and design but others say it more based on the humanistic disciplines than scientific discipline, to cognize which manner is perfect truly depends on the manner a certain organisation usage to implement and reexamine its scheme.

Strategic direction is all about cognizing the strategic place of a company, strategic options for future and the alteration the scheme into proper actions. It consists of analysis of both external and internal house ‘s environments analysis of the house ‘s towards doing strategic determinations and accomplishing long term organisation ‘s ends, ( Johnson G, 2005 ) . Besides strategic direction can besides be defined as the extraction of present actions for the hereafter and in bend going an action vehicle so as to incorporate and commit the setup of alteration. ( Kanter R M, 1984 ) .

Scheme can be formulated by three different degrees which are named as corporate degree, concern unit degree and functional or cardinal degree. Corporate degree scheme fundamentally deals with the choice of concern in which an administration will vie and with the development of portfolio of that concern. It is besides concerned with searching and explicating the things that are responsible in corporate, these are like placing overall ends of the corporation, types of concern in which the organisation should be involved and the overall manner in which the concern should be integrated and managed.Coming down to the 2nd degree of scheme which is concern unit degree, this literally trades with developing and prolonging a competitory advantage for the goods that are produced by the company.

Harmonizing to Michael Porter, the three generic schemes which are identified in this degree are cost leading, distinction and focal point, these can be implemented so as to make a competitory advantage and support against the inauspicious effects of the five forces.The last degree on the degrees of scheme is the functional degree ; this degree includes the operation divisions and sections. The strategic issues at the functional degree are related to concern procedures and the value concatenation. Functional degree schemes in selling, finance, operations and human resources involve the development and coordination of resources through which concern unit degree schemes can be executed expeditiously and efficaciously.

Mintzberg divided scheme into two groups which are normative schools which involves design school, be aftering school and place school. And the other group is descriptive schools which include entrepreneurial school, cognitive school, larning school, power school, cultural school, environmental school and constellation school, ( Mintzberg, Ahlstrand & A ; Lampel, 2008 ) .The design school is responsible for the development of the Strength Weaknesses Opportunities and Threats ( SWOT ) theoretical account. In this theoretical account the strengths and failings of a company are mapped together with the chances and menaces in the market topographic point.

The informations can be used to analyze assorted strategic options which both exploit the internal chances and expect the market state of affairs.The planning school largely relates with the premises the design school and support techniques particularly the aims, budgets, plans and runing programs of an organisation.which mean that staff contrivers replace senior directors and act as cardinal participants in the organisation.The Positioning School, In this position scheme reduced to places of generic which are chosen through formalistic analysis of industry status and therefore contrivers became analysts.

The Cognitive School, on this descriptive school, there was involvement in the beginning of schemes and if schemes developed in people mind as theoretical accounts what could be understood about those mental procedures? And even go oning today the research has grown steadily on cognitive prejudices in scheme devising and on knowledge as information processing. Besides another new subdivision of cognitive school focal point more on subjective interpretive position of the scheme procedure that knowledge is used to build schemes as originative readings instead than to map world in nonsubjective manner.The Learning School, among all schools which have been discussed learning school became a absolute moving ridge and challenged the wide-reaching normative schools traveling back to early work on construct like emerging scheme or the growth of each individual ‘s determinations instead than being absolutely formulated illustration act in order to believe every bit much as think in order to move.The Power School, this perfectly little but a spot different school which focused on scheme devising from the power which is in two senses that is micro power and macro power.

The first power which is micro power looks on the development of schemes within the organisation and it is the procedure affecting bargaining, persuasion, and confrontation among inside histrions. And the 2nd one macro power this treats the organisation as an entity which uses its authorization over others organisations and among its spouses inA confederations, A joint ventures, and so on to negociate corporate schemes for the organisation involvements.TheA CulturalA School, this school goes face-to-face to the power school that based on single involvement and atomization. Besides it explains the norms and attitudes that one carry while implementing the scheme the civilization conditions have to be taken into consideration since organisation civilization differentiates one administration consistence over a long period of clip.

There by to alter the civilization is an Art of challenge to the administration to do its administration adapt alterations. ( Wilson. I 2003 )The last 1 is environmental school. This school takes strategic formation as a reactive procedure.

This school has got the beginning in eventuality theory, which developed to travel against the confident averments of classical direction that there is merely one best manner to run the organisation.Prescriptive school of scheme is a particular class of action design to accomplish aims, this school trades with scheme preparation than with how they needfully do organize ( Mintzberg, Ahlatrand and Lampel, 1998 ) .In normative attack the scheme development is a systematic manner and deterministic procedure whereby it helps to analyse the organisation internal and external environment which can assist them to explicate scheme based on their organisation environment, ( Kennedy 2007 ) . The organisation plans in this school can take long period to come up with concluding determinations before implement scheme.

In this school senior director is in charge of decide the concluding aims and programs before put into action in different degrees of the organisation.Prescriptive school besides is giving guidelines or model procedure that should be followed to plan a scheme, in this instance he mention this procedure as the designer who is constructing a house based on the design which hes formulated before ( Mintzberg,1998 )In normative theoretical account the strategic formation in this school has taken different attacks and procedure that rational and fact based analysis of the options will present the scheme that is most like to be successful, it explain different attacks which strategic procedure has to follow in order to come up with the good schemes, illustration the theoretical account has use different techniques to come up with the write schemes, one of the technique has being explain by Michael porter five forces, this can be used in this school in order to analyse its bing rivals, ( Lynch 2006, pg 18 ) .The scheme formation in normative school is a logical attack which allows the organisation to invent prognostic and pre emptive schemes from which they can run into new chances in future. For illustration easy jet in 1995 has introduced low cost flights which has allow the company to take advantage of more cost witting in the market, ( Volderba ; A ; Elfring 2001 ) .

Therefore this attack has made possible for the company to form activities and exercising a greater grade of control over different concerns. Besides the normative scheme theoretical account contain many premises that are unsustainable in today ‘s concern universe, based on its attack that scheme development is ever calculated and that scheme are implemented harmonizing to the organisation programs.Prescriptive scheme theoretical account can hence be described as a more degage and systematic procedure of formal top down rational planning procedure for development and execution of schemes which related to the mission and aims of the organisation, and the procedure of strategic devising is supported by techniques with consideration of aims, plans, budgets and runing programs. This procedure assist the organisation recognizing organisation jobs, set uping and measuring the planning standards and make alternate, ( Hill, Jones, and Galvin, 2004 ) .

In comparing with the normative scheme, the 2nd group mentioning to Mintzberg is known as descriptive schools of scheme. This can good be defined as the strategic formation which deals with the wide influence of strategic way of the house ( Anderson an Norman 2002 ) . Strategic formation in descriptive based on the mental procedure. Besides it analyse how people perceive forms and procedure of formation.

Harmonizing to Mintzberg the descriptive scheme may be different from normative scheme in a manner that they have different attacks and applications in the existent life. In the descriptive scheme attack, the scheme formation can be done utilizing the past experience ; therefore the scheme which can be formed utilizing this school can be through the procedure of acquisition, accommodations and experimentation. In extra to that Mintzberg insisted that in this school scheme can be unplanned, developing incrementally over clip as concern actions adapt to altering world, the strategic formation procedure did non place a concluding aim with a specific scheme to accomplish this which means it relies on the development schemes whose concluding result may non be known ( Mintzberg, Lampel, Quinn and Ghoshal, 2004 ) .On the other manus descriptive scheme is fundamentally focused on the past grounds.

Unlike the descriptive, the normative takes other factors in history while analysing multi [ lupus erythematosus standards and conflicting expostulations. so choose precisely what scheme can make realistically based on the aims listed. A descriptive attack makes determinations on different subjects based on past experience.If it was positive, and so the determination is made.

If it is negative so a different determinations made. Prescriptive scheme travel go throughing all options and analyze them before make up one’s minding based on all factors which one is the best option to utilize.Besides by following Mintzberg analogy, normative scheme is said to scriptural in its attack, it appears at a point in clip and is governed by a set of regulation s, to the full formulated and ready to implement.While the descriptive scheme is Darwinian in attack, an emerging and altering scheme that survives by accommodating as the environment itself changes.

Given the demand for an administration to hold a corporate scheme, much has truly been about the procedure of accomplishing these schemes. No common manner understanding on the manner this can be done.In extra to that, the descriptive schools of idea are more realistic side of scheme. As they are non bound by any jurisprudence.

They are capable of altering the environment in their ain favor as a great enterpriser is capable of making it. It is really much clearly and easy seeable in the devising of McDonald ‘s and Benetton who are led by great enterprisers.While, maintaining in head the factor of environment, it is sometimes considered to be as noncomprehensive, which is dealt by Cognitive and Learning schools. These ideas bring in front the relevancy of emerging with clip and respects larning as an on-going procedure.

These schools emphasizes on doing a wide policy and go forthing some infinite for alteration in the center due to the belief that a alteration might originate from any sub-system within any section in the administration. These ideas are clearly seeable in instance of the entryway of HONDA motors in the USA market which became successful with clip and emerged as leaders in the market.In decision we can literally state that due to the alteration in environmental factors and high competition in concern due to globalization therefore concern scheme can non be a seated duck but a traveling mark that is to state the organisation scheme has to be developed in each peculiar clip illustration some companies which are so advanced and do non utilize inactive scheme they change their scheme by creativeness and invention harmonizing to alterations go oning therefore holding that concern scheme is more of an art than a scientific discipline. Hence successful concern will be modifying it scheme with clip to suit into the environment and travel frontward. 

Cite this page

Differences and similarities between prescriptive and descriptive schools of strategy. (2017, Jul 22). Retrieved from


Remember! This essay was written by a student

You can get a custom paper by one of our expert writers

Order custom paper Without paying upfront