Humans are naturally emotional creatures. Yet without the guidance and foresight that arises with using logic and reason, decision making influenced by emotions is often rash and destructive. Using logic and reason allows one to carefully calculate the payoff of each decision, as well as the potential risks involved. This can be applied to various situations in life, whether one is using logic in a game of chess or a financial decision in a business.
However, countless instances in history and iterate have shown us the effect one’s emotions may have on the ability to make logical decisions, such as the tragic deaths in Shakespearean “Romeo and Juliet, and Ender from Mender’s Game. In the play “Romeo and Juliet”, Juliet devises a plan to escape from her friends and family, all of whom did not wish for her to be married to Romeo, by faking her death. However, when Romeo discovers her seemingly lifeless body, he is consumed with grief and commits suicide.
When Juliet awakes from her empowers coma, she sees Romeos corpse and commits suicide as well, creating a string of tragic deaths all driven by emotion. Had Romeo not been so overcome with grief, he would have been able to be reunited with Juliet, who awakens only moments later. Juliet, waking so soon after Romeo drinks the poison he had bought, could have ran for help in saving Romeo from the poison. Instead, she is overcome with emotion as well and stabs herself, creating more needless bloodshed. Clearly, because the motions of both Romeo and Juliet clouded their Judgment, both died tragic deaths.
In fact, the root of this conflict in “Romeo and Juliet” could have been entirely prevented if Romeo and Juliet had been reasonable and moderated their love. Instead, they allow their hormonally charged emotions run wild and agree to marry each other only after 3 days of their first meeting. Had reason and logic prevailed, they both could have carefully resolved the tensions between their families and married each other without impediments. Mender’s Game certainly illustrates the awareness of the belief “emotions cloud Judgment”.
All throughout the battles with aliens, the genius 10 year old strategist Ender Wigging is manipulated by adults into believing that the space battles he commanded through holograms were merely simulations, as the adults know that Mender’s empathy for everyone would impair his ability to lead his soldiers. Mender’s Game is a prime example of how the absence of emotions can aid one in battles, as Ender did not know the men he was sending to heir deaths were real, allowing him to fully exert his strategic brilliance and make sacrifices where needed.
It is due to the fact that humans are born with empathy and naturally relate to other humans that we are susceptible to emotions affecting our judgment and rendering us conflicted as to the “right choice”. However, by utilizing pure logic and careful calculations, one is able to carry out the best possible solution or decision and achieve one’s goal. Rational vs. Emotional Decision Making By Southampton