Compare and Contrast Berger and Bordo Essay
Compare and Contrast Berger and Bordo
The paper presents a comparison between two books, Ways of Seeing and Beauty (Re) discovers the Male Body. Both books cover a common feature, i.e. the human body.
Ways of Seeing by John Berger:
The massive amount of approach methodologies to be recommended by “Ways of Seeing” is revealed in its work of art – if that is the expression. Even though consisting of a number of compositions, together spoken in addition to completely illustrative, Berger unambiguously recommends the person who reads, the book commences in a fanciful and inspirational approach previously on the book’s cover, to go all the way through them in no matter what order he desires, his most important endeavor simply being to raise queries. This to a certain extent changeable methodology rather difficult to understand the combine – and without doubt unsettle – subject of the work: as an alternative of investigating what ability does to us, it inquires about what we – as audience, opponents, customers, proprietors and consumers – are doing to art. It is regarding the traditions in which art provides to legitimize, maintain and cover up societal dissimilarity. The fundamental characteristics are: category, sexual characteristics and consumerism.
To position the juncture for his learning that expressively is restricted to representative illustrations Berger initially releases the conventional approach of art’s olden times as disorientation. Conceptions of aesthetics – and in exacting those of composition – he disagrees, have included themselves among addressees and work of art to ambiguous and hinder any instantaneous observation of the community substance of pictures. In this method, conditions as, for instance, spatial separation, graceful understanding and shade distinction are established in an endeavor to describe for the concentration and expressive accusation of a representation whereas several impartial assessments would disclose these moderately to recline in the communal inconsistencies involving the individuals illustrated, or among their world and that of the viewer.
Once the movie of intellectual bewilderment is detached, simplicity, accuracy, strength, sheen and verisimilitude disclose the most important features of European oil painting: the demonstration of objects prosperity. Subsequent the thoughts of Levi-Strauss, Berger puts in plain words that the improvement of this specific art method and art type and its extraordinary increase in the 15th century by the requirement of a promising category of commercial entrepreneurs, and soon after the landed gentry, to corroborate their good judgment of possession and the significance of resources.
Set contained by a theoretical configuration that registers the route of European oil pictures as the challenge to idealize the misapprehension of tangibility it is no surprise that “Ways of Seeing” provides meticulous consideration to the interpretation of women. Even though the ultimate inspection that it was principally prearranged to demand to the audience/representative’s sexuality – should have appeared usual even at the time of inscription Berger, in the procedure of his assessment, commences a quantity of motivating thoughts on the distinction among “nakedness”, to be exclusive of concealing outfit, to be oneself and “nudity”, to be positioned on exhibition in a conceptualized approach, to be an entity in European drawing (John Berger, 150).
Extreme less controversial than in the rationale of oil painting “Ways of Seeing” recognizes the inspiration of possession as well as essential to the appreciation of contemporary announcement. There, exchange is accessible as the alteration of one’s identity into an improved a “better-off” method of existing. By buying the anticipated manufactured goods we turn out to be the cheerful – and flourishing individuals illustrated and the jealousy of others. In this respect, announcement and advertisement resides on and motivates the dissatisfaction with the current to grasp out the expectations. Certainly, here “Ways of Seeing” chooses up on its supporting subject, this expectation merely concentrates on the private existence of the human being and by this means redirects concentration from the requirement for collective transformation.
In the company of the insertion of contemporary announcement “Ways of Seeing” – this subsequent to all is a very thin manuscript – contract with five hundred years of drawing: its techniques, procedures, varieties, topics and artistes. This presents in the least professional adequate space to discover exceptions, exclusions, disagreements and opposites and destroy the book into sections. On the other hand, “Ways of Seeing” is not inscribed for the specialized identification but for the accurately communication, wide-eyed. In a field in which more and more concentrates manuscripts, on books on representations, proliferate this is the increasingly significant demand to approach back to our sanity.
Beauty (Re) Discovering the Male Body by Susan Bordos:
“Beauty (Re) discovers the Male Body”, a section from the segment “Public Images”, is regarding the male body as a public representation. Susan Bordo talks about the utilization of the male body in unrestricted marketing.
She establishes out by illuminating her earliest incident with the male body as an illustration profitable representation. She says that the illustration was so shocking and surprising that it made her to spill out her coffee, and she got a lot of pleasure from the representation that she saved it as her screen saver so that she could watch on the picture at whatever time she required. She goes on to converse regarding how fixing your eyes on at one’s self can turn out to be addicting. She confesses that when somebody compliments her on her appearance, her feelings can transform significantly.
She says that the emotion of somebody staring at her makes her consider sexy, and a lot of women happen to be enthusiastic to this sensation. Subsequently, she puts in plain words the dissimilarities in fashions involving men and women. Conventionally, women are hypothetical to be substance for concentration, and men are theoretical to be a heartrending objective. This means that they are thought to be matters of flight of the imagination. On the other hand, in today’s civilization men are being thought of as substance to fix your eyes on ahead. Men are at this moment being utilized in community advertisements as sexual descriptions, demanding to be a magnet for women so that they will look on the male imageries.
In this composition, Beauty (Re) Discovering the Male Body, Bordo is clearing up the development of classified ad advertisements. Males are at the moment being drawn on as sexual substances. She as well talks about the advancement of advertisements concerning minorities. At this instant, minorities are extensively employed in announcement, and furthermore dissimilar competitions are utilized for diverse rationales (Peggy Zeglin Brand, 112). It is understandable that the media is developing the descriptions that are employed in publications and illustration ads so that males and minorities are extensively applied to be a focus for others so that they will provide the critiques and advertisements a second glance, and perhaps a third or fourth.
Bordo clarifies how and why she earliest got involved in appearing for latest commercials of males in publications. Bordo unequivocally portrays her opinions on how citizens glance at the male body, how it was used in promotion, movie theaters, and our civilization in general. She moreover goes into how more instances the exploit of male bodies has distorted in our traditions. Bordo makes use of a bundle of pictures and genuine announcements to illustrate you in as a person who reads and get you thoughts regarding the representation of male physical type in your personal manner. The writer utilizes a lot of most important garments corporations as examples for her interpretations like Calvin Klein, Haggar, Dockers, and Gucci. She articulates that these corporations and further have covered the technique for the utilization of male bodies as “sexual objects” on intention. Her inspiration relies on the complete conviction that masculinity sales, which it does. Her judgments go in deepness on this area under discussion, as far as to speak gay stylists assisted the world all along with this thought.
She goes into enormous specifications regarding how the planet is at the moment preoccupied with appearing slender and powerfully built or healthy. From this conventionality she makes clear that commercials and movie theaters have misrepresented to healthy the altering inhabitants. She brings into play a previous instance of John Travolta and how he was illustrated in Saturday Night Fever as a younger gentleman and afterward bended forward up and carved like a Greek figurine for the development continuing living. She communicates how she is old shaped and desired the male body may perhaps be described as further accepted at the present time.
On comparing the books, it can be concluded that these books give a detailed description of how the human body was used and how is it being used now. The way these books are written is a quite captivating method. The reader sticks to the place until is done with the entire book. Although the books contain a bit of explicit material and images, but they somehow balance the interest that is developed throughout the reading. The books are a perfect combination of the future and the present of the advertising and marketing field. The way the art is discussed in the books is really captivating and is a must read for any art lover.
Berger, John. Ways of seeing. Published by British Broadcasting Corporation, 1972
Brand, Peggy Zeglin. Beauty Matters. Published by Indiana University Press 2000