Renaissance DBQ Sample Essay
During the Renaissance clip period. each adult male and adult female needed to endeavor to run into the “ideal” image that was expected by society. If this image was non met. the individual would be judged by society. Both males and females had different ends that they needed to run into in instruction. every bit good as in their lives. While there was an “ideal” image. some people disagreed with them. There was ever a distinguishable function for both adult females and work forces. but within those functions. there could be controversy. The most contention could happen over the instruction that the males and females were acquiring. there were clear functions and ideals for work forces and adult females in the beginning of the Renaissance clip period. but as clip went on. people became more disbelieving of the instruction system.
In Renaissance clip. both work forces and adult females had different societal outlooks. both expected to be educated. but they were to be educated in different ways. Work force were expected to travel through school and be good educated. They needed to cognize how to believe and to compose decently so that they could acknowledge the educated people around them. This instruction would assist them to be all-around in life. every bit good as happen a good adult female. Castiglione believed all people needed to endeavor for this in order to be successful.
( 3 ) While the work forces were pressured to analyze difficult and go independent minds. adult females were non encouraged in the same manner. Womans should be taught. but they should be taught different things and they should be taught in a different mode. Their instruction should concentrate chiefly on the classics. Womans were non taught so that they could believe. but it was said books have one intent for adult females. “…let the books teach her good manners…”
( 5 ) Womans needed to concentrate on the classics and non over-analyze them because that was non their function in society. They should hold a basic cognition so they can do the work forces look good. but they should non be believing and making new thoughts. ( 5 ) Ideally. they would larn rudimentss. and so make family jobs and learn their kids how to decently make them. ( 9 ) Womans were chiefly expected to do their hubbies look good. and the intelligence would be up to the work forces.
As clip progressed. people became more critical of the functions of the work forces in society based on the instruction that they were having. In the beginning. their instruction was considered compulsory. and it was looked down upon if one did non purely analyze in school. ( 3 ) However. as clip went on. people realized that non merely was instruction in the schoolroom of import. but proper etiquette and life accomplishments were required to hold a successful life. Men needed to cognize how to make common topographic point things in order to win and hold a full rounded life. If work forces did non cognize how to “…ride. play. dance and sing. and dress well…” so they would non hold even a background for how to populate.
( 6 ) Traveling along with cognizing these other common accomplishments. a adult male would hold to cognize how to use what he learned in a schoolroom to his existent life. Men needed to be taught more about their ethical motives. and the classics of life. non merely memorisation. If they merely memorized. so they had to wait until college to set what they learned into topographic point. By waiting to hold people use the accomplishments they learned. they are put at a great disadvantage because true larning comes from an application of the accomplishments learned. ( 8. 13 ) The feelings toward the educational system had drastically changed and people were going much more disbelieving of what they were larning.
Not merely were people going more disbelieving of the educational system as clip went on. but they were besides oppugning the demand of all people to hold an instruction. Baldassare Castiglione stressed that if a adult male wanted to be successful. the lone manner to accomplish this would be acquire a proper instruction. He said that this would take to a good married woman. every bit good as a good life. Ideally. this should hold been all men’s ends. ( 3 ) Castiglione looked at people from a higher degree in society and looked down on the remainder of the people and the manner that they acted. He explicitly stated that the people needed to “…be reasonably learned in the Humanities…” ( 3 ) .
There were certain facets of larning that he emphasized more than the others. Not merely did he concentrate on major plants that the people should cognize but besides on “…writing in poetry and prose…” ( 3 ) Castiglione had the ideal image in his head of precisely what people needed to be and the manner they should move. When he said this. it was greatly respected because of his authorship of his well-known behavior book. However. people began to swerve off from this ideal of a needful instruction ; it became a major alteration for society.
Subsequently on. in the Letter to the Parlement of Dijon refering the reopening of a Gallic Jesuit school. it was explicitly said that all work forces do non necessitate an instruction. Some work forces need to make work that is non based off of instruction ; they need to make the rudimentss that make society properly map. “The survey of literature is appropriate merely to a little minority of work forces. ”
This statement explicitly says that an instruction is non for everyone. boldly traveling against Castiglione. ( 11 ) This was a bold statement to do. because it showed a drastic alteration in people’s point of position of a proper adult male. Along with stating non all people needed to be educated. there was besides the huge unfavorable judgment of the school system and the manner it was learning. The constructs being learned in school needed to be more readily applied into existent life state of affairss. and this did non look to be the true end. ( 8 )
While there was huge alteration in the position of the instruction of work forces. there was non a recognizably large alteration in the position of the instruction of adult females. Their primary end in life was to do their hubbies look good. If they did desire to do themselves educated. it should merely be in the classics and there should non be anything new that they attempt to ask. ( 5 ) The ideal adult female would cognize how to make house keep jobs and have a basic cognition in instruction. Womans were expected to cognize expressed things. such as “…embroidery. reading. authorship. and dancing…” ( 9 ) They should non merely cognize these things. but they should go through them on to their girls so they can be better taught every bit good. ( 9 ) Women chiefly kept the same function in society throughout these old ages.
Throughout clip. people disagreed over the instruction of males and females. altering the ideals of what needed to be taught and focused on. but through all of this. there remained distinguishable functions for the work forces and adult females. The ideals of society began to alter when people became more disbelieving of the manner they had been larning and life.
When work forces realized that they did non cognize how to to the full use accomplishments they learned until they were at an older age. it made them oppugn the system of instruction. Once people had begun to believe on their ain about their society it raised jobs and contention. Womans were ne’er taught to believe about the things around them. they merely accepted them and did what would do them “ideal” . Throughout clip. when people question society. there will usually be a alteration. but the deepness of the alteration depends on how much the people think about it.