Advantages And Disadvantages Of Design And Build Method Construction

Table of Content

While building contracts serves as a agency of pricing building, they besides construction the allotment of hazard to the assorted parties involved.

The building field is a really extended and alone in each undertaking. In this universe most of the undertakings are managed by contracts.

This essay could be plagiarized. Get your custom essay
“Dirty Pretty Things” Acts of Desperation: The State of Being Desperate
128 writers

ready to help you now

Get original paper

Without paying upfront

And as a rule to pull off the undertaking efficaciously we should foremost pull off the contracts.

The proprietor has the exclusive power to make up one’s mind what type of contract & A ; bringing method should be used for a specific installation to be constructed and to put forth the footings in a contractual understanding.

A house has to take the right bringing method which is undertaking to project base and present its command offer to the engineer/client during tendering phase to enable it to show competitory monetary value and win the undertaking without compromising the functional and the quality of the undertaking.

Choosing the right method to present the undertaking will ease the undertaking executing and give flexibleness during building every bit good as salvaging money and clip for a house and later the same to the proprietor.

It is of import to understand the hazards of the contractors associated with different type of bringing methods.

In this blink of an eye you may inquire what the contract bringing methods are and we should take the right bringing methods.

Undertakings bringing methods.

There are three types of undertaking bringing methods. In this subdivision we will concentrate on design and Build because it s the best method for little and average undertakings.

1- Tender or design-bid-build method

In this type the owner/client will take applied scientist to plan the whole undertaking and acquire the

Blessings from governments so drifting stamp to take suited contractor for the Construction under his supervising.

In this type of method the client /engineer has full control of the undertaking and the contractor has to follow with full design given by the applied scientist.

Most suited type of contract for this method is lump amount contract which the monetary value given by the Contractor is fixed and the whole undertaking is already designed and the range of work is clear and to the full detailed.

2-indefinite measure contract method

Under this type of contract there shall be no design and it is based on care or mending undertakings.

Under this understanding the proprietor and the contractor will upfront put up monetary values for the labours and Equipments and markup etc

3- Design and construct method.

The term “ design-build ” refers to a scope of options to the traditional undertaking bringing system.

A utile manner to look at design-build is by what it is non. Traditional design-bid-build is a metameric, consecutive procedure in which the proprietor foremost contracts

With a design professional to fix elaborate, suitable-for-construction programs and specifications ( or Sometimes has them prepared by its in-house applied scientists ) , so uses the elaborate programs and Specifications to beg competitory commands for building, and eventually present the building Contract to the low bidder.

Design-build ‘ means a procurement procedure in which both the design and building of

A undertaking is procured from a individual contractor.

Normally, the design-build contract is awarded by some procedure other than competitory command Supplying the best value ( in monetary value, characteristics, maps [ and ] life-cycle costs )

Therefore, design-build differs from traditional design-bid-build in two ways. First, the design and building constituents are packaged into a individual contract. Second, the individual contract is non needfully awarded to the low bidder after competitory command

I-Why Design-Build? ( Advantages )

Potential Cost Savingss

Design-build has the possible to cut down over-all undertaking cost because the design-build contractor executing the design has a better feel for the building cost of assorted options, Therefore can come up with a design that is less expensive to construct and has an inducement to make so. Another manner to look at this advantage is that it moves value technology “ cost decrease inducement ”

After contract award ( with the contractor suggesting cost-reduction thoughts and sharing the nest eggs with the proprietor ) to pre-award ( with the proprietor basking most of the cost nest eggs ) .

B. Earlier Project Completion

Design-build may ensue in earlier completion and tenancy of the undertaking because there is no Dead clip between completion of design and start of building. Further, the design-build Contractor can get down building of early stages of the undertaking ( e.g. mobilisation, site public-service corporations, Foundations ) before design of ulterior stages ( constructing envelope, interior dividers, HVAC, electrical ) Is 100 per centum complete? This procedure sometimes is referred to as “ fast path. ”

C. Reduced Claims Exposure

Design-build eliminates the liability spread. Design professionals can obtain insurance coverage merely for negligent mistakes and skips, and virtually all design contracts limit the interior decorator ‘s liability to such.

However, there can be non-negligent mistakes and skips, which cost the proprietor money but for which the design professional is non apt. For illustration, a design professional may set about Reasonable subsurface probes but fail to observe a stone outcropping that will necessitate extra work.

In the traditional design-bid-build attack, the proprietor warrants the rightness of the programs and Specifications to the building contractor.

There can be design errors for which the proprietor is apt to the building contractor under the Warranty of rightness but can non reassign the liability on to the design professional.

Even when the interior decorator is in fact negligent, turn outing carelessness can be hard.

The proprietor must obtain a certification of virtue from another design professional and so turn out that the interior decorator failed to run into the applicable professional criterion of attention, which requires adept testimony.

On the other manus, the contractor normally can turn out there was a defect in the programs that cost the Contractor money based on fact testimony entirely.

Therefore, the proprietor may hold to bear the cost.

Design- physique eliminates this spread because the design-bid physique entity has no 1 but itself to fault For faulty programs and specifications or differing site conditions.

D. New Technologies

Public Contracts normally prohibits brand-name or model-number specifications unless the

Specification lists at least two trade name names and is followed by the phrase “ or equal. ”

This makes it hard for traditional design-bid-build to make advanced, proprietary

Merchandises where there may be merely one brand-name and no equal.

Further, permutation of a new “ or equal ” merchandise for a standard merchandise frequently is infeasible Because of the ripple consequence.

The interior decorator designs the undertaking around current coevals Merchandises and permutation of new “ or equal ” merchandises after command can necessitate alterations to construction, mechanical or electrical constituents to suit the new merchandise.

Who is traveling to pay for these ripplings alterations? Design-build resolutenesss this job.

The design-build contractor selects the equipment ( right down to do and pattern figure ) and Then designs the edifice around the selected equipment, which is a more logical manner to continue.

In fact, the design-build contractor can sometimes obtain free design aid from equipment Manufacturers wanting that their new engineerings be used.

E. Over-All Project Optimization

Design-bid-build can endure from sub-optimization when person undertaking participants optimise their ain places, frequently at the disbursal of the over-all undertaking.

The entire cost to the proprietor of a edifice component, such as the steel frame, includes the cost of the technology to find the needed steel subdivisions plus the cost of the steel.

The interior decorator has little incentive to utilize a crisp pencil to accomplish the minimal sum of

Structural steel ; he optimizes his ain place by passing merely the design clip necessary to Guarantee that there is adequate steel to run into gravitation and seismal tonss, frequently by using Conservative premises that may ensue in more steel than necessary.

So, the proprietor may salvage money on design but wage for it in steel.

With design-build, on the other manus, the design-build entity has an inducement to utilize the Optimum sum of technology. Equally long as an extra dollar of technology will salvage more than one dollar ‘s worth of steel, the design-build contractor will pass the technology clip up To the point of decreasing returns when an extra dollar ‘s worth of technology saves merely a Dollar s worth of steel because both the cost of design and the cost of steel come out of the same pocket.

This is non to state that design-build consequences in flimsy or less-safe constructions. “ More ” ( steel,

concrete, etc. ) is non needfully “ better. ” Simply stipulating excess steel or concrete in one topographic point because the applied scientist does non hold the clip or inducement to cipher precisely how much is really required does non better the over-all public presentation of the edifice.

“ A concatenation is merely every bit strong as its weakest nexus. ” If the proprietor wants a edifice with higher floor Loadings, less floor warp or opposition to a bigger temblor than required by codification, so The manner to accomplish this is by puting that demand on the design-build entity up front non by Hoping that the interior decorator will throw in some excess steel or concrete because he or she does non hold clip in the budget to utilize a crisp pencil.

F.Reduced Administrative Burden

Design-build may cut down the administrative load on the proprietor because there is one solicitation, one award and one contract to administrate.

G. Earlier Cost Visibility

The entire cost of the undertaking is evident before with design-build. In traditional design-bid-build, Construction costs are non known until command gap, and it is possible to pass money on a design that the bureau can non afford to construct. All excessively frequently, building commands exceed the budget, and the Undertaking must be re-designed to convey it within the budget, therefore detaining completion.

H. Agency CM with Multi-Prime Contracts

One of the advantages of design-build can be achieved by a building direction ( CM ) to Manage design and over-all undertaking coordination and so undertaking straight with several contractors, which are so managed by the CM.

Construction undertaking direction s services provided by a accredited designer, registered applied scientist, or licensed general contractor.

Under this attack, the early stages of the undertaking ( earthwork, site public-service corporations, and foundations ) can be placed under contract before design of the edifice shell and inside is 100 per centum complete, and the structural steel and other long lead-time constituents can be ordered.

Then, the contracts for the early stages can be awarded to follow-on contractors.

There are two types of building directors.

An bureau CM is a adviser to the proprietor ; an bureau CM is non in the concatenation of privity between The proprietor and the contractor ( s ) and does non vouch the cost of the work.

An at-risk CM, on the other manus, basically is a brokering general contractor.

The at-risk CM is either in the concatenation of privity between the proprietor and the trade contractors or Guarantees that the aggregative monetary value of the contracts will non transcend some maximal figure.

Any single or steadfast proposing to supply building undertaking direction services shall supply Evidence that the person or house and its forces transporting out onsite duties have Expertise and experience in building undertaking design reappraisal and rating, building Mobilization and supervising, command rating, undertaking programming, cost-benefit analysis, claims Review and dialogue, and general direction and disposal of a building undertaking.

Which type of contract is better for design-build?

Most suited type of contracts is lump amount contract because the proprietor has basically assigned all the hazards to the contractor, who in bend can be expected to inquire for a higher markup in order to take Care of unanticipated eventualities.

Beside the fixed ball amount monetary value, other committednesss are frequently made by the contractor in the signifier of submittals such as a specific agenda, the direction coverage system or a quality control Program.

If the existent cost of the undertaking is underestimated, the underestimated cost will cut down the Contractor s net income by that sum. An overestimation has an opposite consequence, but may cut down the Opportunity of being a low bidder for the undertaking.

The range of work, the monetary value, the clip of public presentation is already defined.

Normally the contractors include allowance for eventualities in their command monetary value so the monetary value

Small and medium undertakings are most suited for this sort of undertaking where is the design is easy non Complicated and can be managed by one party.


The possible advantages of design-build do non come without hazard.

A. Less Control.

Under traditional design-bid-build, the proprietor has full control over the inside informations of the programs and Specifications and does non print them for commands until it is satisfied that they reflect its Requirements, including functional and aesthetic penchants.

With design-build, the proprietor gives up some of this control. i.e. , progressing the degree of design through the design development phase ( 30 per centum or so ) before award of the design-build contract.

Of class, by making so the proprietor may give up some of the advantages of design-build.

B. Need for Earlier Requirements Definition

With design-build, the proprietor must lock in its demands much earlier.

With traditional design-bid-build, if the proprietor is a small fuzzy on its functional or aesthetic Requirements, it can clear up them during the design stage after if sees where the interior decorator is heading.

But with design-bid-build, post-award programmatic alterations can be really expensive and riotous.

C. Recommendation

So, if the metropolis ( state ) regulations are non certain what it wants, traditional design-bid-build may be the better option.

D. Compliance with Subcontractors

The Subletting and Subcontracting Fair Practices Act, requires that bidders list their subcontractors with their commands. This can be a job for a design-build bidder. Without elaborate design drawings, the subcontractors can non exactly estimate costs.

But, naming a subcontractor without a house subcontract monetary value puts the design-build contractor at a disadvantage in later pricing the subcontract work.

A listed subcontractor has the premier design-build contractor over the proverbial barrel. This is a manageable job for a design-build contractor with many of the same type of undertakings in an Area, as a subcontractor can merely acquire away with force outing the design-build entity one time.

Parking garages and lodging are good illustrations of where the design-build entities work with a group of subcontractors on a insistent footing, and subcontractors can gauge their work on a perspace. or.pre-square.foot.basis.

Design-build contractor shall seek for competitory commands for subcontracts non listed with its premier command.

The job with this attack is that it depends on specific legislative mandates that do non use to the state.

Therefore, the safest attack may be to necessitate listing of subcontractors at clip of command, even though this may ensue in either the subcontractors or the premier design-build entity including some eventuality and mark-up.

E. Payment bonds

By and large it is required a payment bond collectible by the footings of the contract.

However, when the design services and the building are procured under a individual contract, must the payment bond be in the full sum of the design-build contract or merely in the sum of the Construction part? Logically, it would look that 100 per centum of the building part would carry through the purpose of the legislative act.

Cite this page

Advantages And Disadvantages Of Design And Build Method Construction. (2016, Dec 06). Retrieved from

Remember! This essay was written by a student

You can get a custom paper by one of our expert writers

Order custom paper Without paying upfront