Short Essay – Typhoid Mary Mallon

Read Summary

Mary Mallon, also known as Typhoid Mary, was not the only healthy carrier of typhoid fever, as an estimated 90-135 new carriers were created each year. Although Mary was responsible for 47 illnesses and three deaths, another carrier, Tony Labella, caused 122 illnesses and five deaths. Mary was confined for over 25 years, in part because of her refusal to follow health officials’ rules after being told of her contagious status. However, other carriers also disobeyed orders without such severe consequences. Mary’s harsh treatment may have been due to her identity as an Irish immigrant woman from the working lower class, as well as her violent temper and denial of her carrier status. She was ultimately quarantined permanently to prevent further spread of the disease. Her case raises questions about balancing individual rights with public health concerns and how to incentivize cooperation with health policies. The health department failed to help Mary find long-term gainful employment after her release, leading her to return to cooking, and potentially spreading the disease again.

Table of Content

Although Mary Mallon was the first healthy carrier identified, she was not the only healthy carrier to spread typhoid fever to others. It is estimated that about three percent of those who had typhoid became carriers, meaning 90-135 new carriers were created each year. Neither was Mary Mallon even the deadliest healthy carrier. Mary made 47 people ill and killed three while Tony Labella, another healthy carrier, caused 122 people to become ill and five deaths. Labella was only isolated for two weeks and then released while Mary was confined in total for over 25 years. Perhaps they confined her for so long because she broke the health officials’ rules after being told of her contagious status. However she too was not the only one to disobey orders. Alphonse Cotils, a restaurant and bakery owner, was told not to prepare food for other people and when health officials found him back at work, they agreed to let him go free when he promised to conduct his business over the phone. Why was such harsh action taken on Mary Mallon?

Look more: typhoid mary essay

This essay could be plagiarized. Get your custom essay
“Dirty Pretty Things” Acts of Desperation: The State of Being Desperate
128 writers

ready to help you now

Get original paper

Without paying upfront

Mallon’s identity contributed to the extreme treatment she suffered. Mallon was an Irish immigrant woman from the working lower class. She cooked because she earned a decent living and then she was wretched from her life and confined for two years. When she was released she was not permitted to go back to the job that had sustained her before. She also did not have the skills necessary to find another job that paid just as well as being a cook. The New York City Health Commissioner who had released her in 1910 helped her find a job doing laundry but it did not provide the wages or job satisfaction to which she had previously become accustomed. The

health department failed in their obligation to help her find long term gainful employment so she inevitably returned to being a cook. Mallon also had a terrible temper. Dr. S. Josephine Baker describes an experience with Mallon as, “She came out fighting and swearing, both of which she could do with appalling efficiency and vigor. I made another effort to talk to her sensibly and asked her again to let me have the specimens, but it was of no use….There was nothing I could do but take her with us. The policemen lifted her into the ambulance and I literally sat on her all the way to the hospital; it was like being in a cage with an angry lion.”

Mallon’s violent temperament probably lent to health officials intolerance and her severe punishment. Her denial in believing in her carrier status also increased her difficulties with the health department. She refused to acknowledge any connection between her working as a cook and the typhoid cases. She believed she was being persecuted unfairly. Mallon maintained she was healthy and had never had typhoid fever so she couldn’t be the source of the outbreaks. Although harsh, public health authorities determined that permanent quarantine was the only way to prevent Mallon from spreading typhoid. Their actions bring up the issue: when do you stop protecting individual rights and start protecting the community? Mallon’s example also raises the point: those who endanger the health of others are more likely to cooperate with officials trying to stem the spread of disease if their economic security were maintained and if they could be convinced that health policies would treat them fairly.

Cite this page

Short Essay – Typhoid Mary Mallon. (2016, Jul 31). Retrieved from

Remember! This essay was written by a student

You can get a custom paper by one of our expert writers

Order custom paper Without paying upfront